Complied AIComplied AI

How does an operational creditor file under IBC section 9?

An unpaid supplier must serve a section 8 demand notice, wait 10 days, then file Form 5 under section 9 for a default of at least ₹1 crore. The steps, the forms and the pre-existing dispute defence.

In this guide
Answer firstVerified 19 November 2026

An operational creditor starts insolvency against a corporate debtor in two steps. First it delivers a demand notice in Form 3, or a copy of the invoice in Form 4, under section 8 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016. If the debtor neither pays nor points to a pre-existing dispute within 10 days, the creditor files a section 9 application in Form 5. The default must be at least ₹1 crore under S.O. 1205(E) of 24 March 2020.

Who is an IBC operational creditor?

An operational creditor is a person owed an operational debt, under section 5(20) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016. Section 5(21) defines operational debt as a claim for goods or services supplied, including employment, or for dues payable to the Central Government, a State Government or a local authority under a law in force. Suppliers, contractors, service vendors and employees fall here. Lenders do not. A bank or anyone else who lent money files as a financial creditor under section 7 instead.

The distinction matters because the procedure differs. A financial creditor goes straight to the Tribunal. An operational creditor has to serve a demand notice first and give the debtor a chance to dispute the claim.

What is an IBC section 8 notice?

The section 8 demand notice is the formal demand an operational creditor must deliver to a corporate debtor before filing. Under section 8(1) and rule 5 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy (Application to Adjudicating Authority) Rules, 2016, the creditor delivers either a demand notice in Form 3 or a copy of the invoice demanding payment in Form 4.

Section 8(2) then gives the debtor 10 days from receipt to do one of two things. It can pay the unpaid operational debt, or it can bring to the creditor's notice a dispute that already exists, such as a pending suit or arbitration, or a record of it.

StepForm or timeProvision
Deliver demand notice or invoiceForm 3 or Form 4Section 8(1), rule 5
Debtor pays or raises dispute10 days from receiptSection 8(2)
File applicationForm 5, after the 10 daysSection 9(1), rule 6
Tribunal admits or rejects14 days from receiptSection 9(5)
Creditor cures a defect7 days from Tribunal noticeProviso to section 9(5)

What is the section 9 minimum default?

The minimum default for a section 9 application is ₹1 crore. Section 4 of the Code lets the Central Government raise the threshold up to ₹1 crore, and it did so by notification S.O. 1205(E) dated 24 March 2020. Before that notification the figure was ₹1 lakh. Defaults below ₹1 crore cannot start a corporate insolvency resolution process, whoever the creditor is.

A worked example. A steel trader supplies a manufacturer under three invoices of ₹45 lakh, ₹40 lakh and ₹30 lakh, all overdue. The total default is ₹1.15 crore, so the threshold is met. The trader delivers a Form 3 demand notice that the manufacturer receives on 3 March. The manufacturer stays silent. The 10 days under section 8(2) end on 13 March, and the trader may file Form 5 from the next day.

If the manufacturer had paid ₹20 lakh during those 10 days, the remaining default would be ₹95 lakh. That is below ₹1 crore, and the application would fail on section 4.

How is a section 9 application filed?

A section 9 application is filed before the National Company Law Tribunal in Form 5, under section 9 and rule 6 of the Application to Adjudicating Authority Rules, 2016. Section 9(3) lists what goes with it:

  1. A copy of the invoice or demand notice delivered to the debtor.
  2. An affidavit that the debtor has not given notice of a dispute about the unpaid debt.
  3. A copy of the certificate from a financial institution keeping the creditor's accounts, confirming no payment was received, where that is available.
  4. Any record with an information utility confirming that the debtor has not paid, if available.
  5. Any other information the Board specifies by regulation.

Under section 9(5)(i), the Tribunal admits the application within 14 days if it is complete, no payment was made, the notice was delivered, no notice of dispute was received and no disciplinary proceeding is pending against any proposed resolution professional. If one of those fails, section 9(5)(ii) requires rejection. The date of admission is the insolvency commencement date, which starts the clock described in our guide to the section 12 CIRP timeline.

What counts as an IBC pre-existing dispute?

A pre-existing dispute is a real dispute about the debt that existed before the debtor received the section 8 demand notice. Section 5(6) defines dispute to include a suit or arbitration about the existence of the debt, the quality of goods or services, or a breach of a representation or warranty. Section 8(2)(a) speaks of a dispute pending "before the receipt of such notice or invoice".

The Supreme Court read this in Mobilox Innovations v. Kirusa Software (2017). The Tribunal does not decide who is right. It checks whether a plausible dispute existed before the notice that needs further investigation. A dispute raised for the first time in reply to the notice, or one that is spurious and unsupported by any record, does not stop admission.

Emails complaining about short supply, a debit note issued before the notice, or correspondence disputing quality usually count. A statement in the reply that "we never accepted the goods", with no earlier trail, usually does not.

What changed in section 9 in 2026?

The Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (Amendment) Act, 2026 changed section 9(3)(e). The clause used to require "such other information, as may be prescribed", which meant rules made by the Central Government. It now reads "any other information, as may be specified", which moves that power to the IBBI through regulations. The IBBI discussion paper of 15 April 2026 records this change.

The IBBI then amended the CIRP Regulations. Its press release IBBI/PR/2026/10 of 4 June 2026 says operational creditors must now file fuller information with the application, including GST records and e-way bills where applicable, and details of part payments, assignments, guarantees and pending proceedings. Check the current text of regulation 2B of the CIRP Regulations before you file, since the list sits in regulations and can change without an amendment to the Code.

IBBI regulation changes and NCLT-facing circulars appear in the IBBI updates feed.

Practical checks

Common questions

A customer owes us ₹60 lakh on unpaid invoices. Can we file under section 9?

No. Section 4 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 sets the minimum default at ₹1 crore, under notification S.O. 1205(E) dated 24 March 2020. A ₹60 lakh claim is below that line, so recovery has to go through a civil suit, arbitration or another remedy.

Can we add up several invoices to reach ₹1 crore?

Yes. The threshold applies to the amount of default owed by the corporate debtor, and that can be made up of several unpaid invoices for the same operational debt. Each invoice should be listed with its due date in the demand notice and in Form 5.

The debtor replied to our demand notice saying the goods were defective. Does that end it?

Usually yes, if the complaint was raised before the demand notice arrived. Section 9(5)(ii)(d) tells the Adjudicating Authority to reject the application where a notice of dispute was received and the dispute existed earlier. A defect complaint invented only after the notice will not carry the same weight.

How long do we wait after delivering the demand notice?

Ten days. Section 8(2) gives the corporate debtor 10 days from receipt of the demand notice to pay or to bring a dispute to the creditor's notice. Section 9(1) allows the application only after those 10 days have run.

Do we have to name an insolvency professional in the application?

No, it is optional. Section 9(4) lets an operational creditor propose a resolution professional to act as interim resolution professional. If the creditor does not, the Adjudicating Authority takes a name from the Board.

How fast must the NCLT decide our section 9 application?

Within 14 days of receipt, under section 9(5). If the application is defective, the Tribunal must give the creditor 7 days from its notice to fix the defect before rejecting it.

Publication method

How this guide was prepared

This guide is published by the Complied AI research desk. Its source list and stated position were checked against the official records shown below on 19 November 2026.

Automation, including AI, may assist research, drafting and structure. It does not replace the official record or amount to an independent professional review. Read our editorial standards and corrections policy.

Verification path

Official sources used

Keep reading

Related guides

Search Complied AI

Laws and sections by number or title, due dates, pages, and updates.